Okay this was the easiest pick. John Miller needed to be a red head and I had an ideal one in the forefront of my memory from the awesome new FNL promo (which is at the bottom of this posting.)
Jesse Plemmons is an amazingly gifted actor. He plays the outrageously intelligent, somewhat inept, thrash rock loving Landry Clark on Friday Night Lights. He would be perfection in the amusing group that is Truth Squad. Plus Jesse’s comic timing is out of this world, he could riff off of a pole if he had to.
Friday Night Lights promo
The Sarah Dessen Diarist 
[…] This Lullaby Casting Remy and Dexter Barbara John Miller […]
John Miller is PERFECT!!! Just put some dirt on his face and make him pout all the time! 😉